What’s Missing in Music Bios? Often What’s Great About the Music

by admin  19th Dec 2013 Comments [1895]
Big Star 3

By Bill Wasserzieher

The problem with many documentaries about solo artists and/or bands is that they “print the legend,” to lift that old line from John Ford’s The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. That is, filmmakers, being storytellers, flesh out the accepted version of their subject’s career—and that’s good for what it is, overviews being useful for the uninitiated—but rarely do they dive deep for what is at the core of the actual art.

To put it another way, is there even one among the scores of Dylan documentaries that digs into his songwriting process? I’d love for the hire-by-the-hour “talking heads” who pop up in them to focus on the creative vision that, for example, produced “Just Like Tom Thumb’s Blues.” Think about those opening lines:

 When you’re lost in the rain in Juarez and it’s Easter-time too,
And your gravity fails and negativity don’t pull you through,
Don’t put on any airs when you’re down on Rue Morgue Avenue,
They got some hungry women and they’ll really make a mess out of you.
 

 These are maybe the bleakest lines since T.S. Eliot was ruminating on “The Hollow Men” and “The Wasteland.” But, no, we always hear about young Bob scuffling in the Village, courting Joan Baez, going electric, retreating to Woodstock, finding/losing/finding religion, ad infinitum. Instead, tell me about those carbolic lines and how his etched-with-acid voice shoves them to the gut.

Jody Stephens, Andy Hummel and Alex Chilton. (Photo courtesy of Magnolia Pictures. Photo credit: William Eggleston, Eggleston Artistic Trust)

Jody Stephens, Andy Hummel and Alex Chilton. (Photo courtesy of Magnolia Pictures. Photo credit: William Eggleston, Eggleston Artistic Trust)

This problem comes to mind with the new and very competently made documentary Big Star: Nothing Can Hurt Me (Magnolia Pictures). The filmmakers present nearly a two-hour overview of a band whose members were young white guys from Memphis—one a former teenage hit-maker with the Box Tops—who cut an indisputably great album, #1 Record, that went unnoticed; followed by another, Radio City, nearly as good and equally ignored; and then a third, Sister Lovers, which was never actually finished, as the players drifted off to different and mostly sad, bad fates.

The filmmakers get the Big Star story from the band drummer Jody Stephens and bassist Andy Hummel, from friends and relatives of deceased members Chris Bell and Alex Chilton, their Ardent recording studio associates (Ardent headman John Fry is the film’s executive producer), an array of rock critics (including a funky old Lester Bangs clip), plus numerous praise-wielding musicians, among them Jim Dickinson, Chris Stamey, Mike Mills, Robyn Hitchcock and Ken Stringfellow.

No denying it’s a well-crafted overview, but what’s missing is serious analysis of the songs and the musicianship on No. 1 Record. What are those songs about? What do say about life as Chris Bell and Alex Chilton were experiencing it, their individual and sometimes at war psyches (Bell bipolar and troubled by sexual identity issues, Chilton bitter, caustic, frequently loaded), and how did their minds and voices work together and separately? These are things crucial to the Big Star story. Otherwise the band was just one of millions that arguably could have been the new Beatles but were not, though at least this one became famous after the fact and served as a fountainhead for power-pop bands that came later.

Alex Chilton. (Photo courtesy of Magnolia Pictures)

Alex Chilton. (Photo courtesy of Magnolia Pictures)

Plus the documentary, while keeping with the legend, plays it cautious. Nowhere is the Alex Chilton I met a few times, first in New York City during the late 1970s when he had a loose ensemble called the Cossacks. One night I asked him about the Big Star records, and he responded,  “Fuck that old shit.” Nearly 25 years later, after he and Jody Stephens reformed Big Star with members of The Posies, I cornered him after a solo show at McCabe’s in Santa Monica, where he had intentionally bummed out a capacity crowd hoping to hear a few Big Star and/or Box Tops tunes by playing instead “Volare” (“Nel blu dip into di blu”) and other songs better suited to a Dean Martin tribute. I asked him why, and he said, “I hate my fans.” Sometimes an artist is his own worst enemy, but Big Star: Nothing Can Hurt Me doesn’t say so.

And that brings to mind those purveyors of commercial/corporate rock, the Eagles. At least the documentary History of the Eagles manages to do more than provide the standard career recap. Glenn Frey, the film’s executive producer and primary talking head, spends three hours trashing everyone who has ever rubbed him wrong—producer Glyn Johns who got the Eagles their first hits, former bandmates Bernie Leadon and Randy Meisner (whose previous stints in Dillard & Clark, the Flying Burrito Bros. and Poco gave the Eagles early credibility), original manager and label boss David Geffen, even Timothy B. Schmit and Joe Walsh who are still contracted sidemen in the band, and especially Don Felder who is reduced to tears when interviewed on how he came to be kicked out.

Chris Bell. (Photo courtesy of Magnolia Pictures)

Chris Bell. (Photo courtesy of Magnolia Pictures)

According to Frey, only he and Don Henley really matter in the grand scheme of things—and that’s why he’s proud to say they get bigger bucks than the others, money apparently his ultimate gauge for success. At no time does Frey ever seem to see beyond his own ego, coming off as vengeful, arrogant and self-absorbed. It’s fascinating and twisted, as creepy as watching footage of performance artist Chris Burden nail himself to the hood of a VW Beatle. But at least it’s more than just another example of “print the legend,” and we do learn something about his band’s songcraft, including that Frey dreamed up the title “Life in the Fast Lane” while roaring through Hollywood at 90 mph in a Corvette driven by his dope dealer on their way to a poker game.

In issue #36 of Ugly Things, Alan Bisbort has a review of a DVD titled A Band Called Death. Comprised of three African-American brothers from Detroit who played rock rather than Motown, the band was good enough for Clive Davis, then the head of Columbia Records, to offer to sign them if they would change their name to something less of a sales-killer than Death. But they wouldn’t, so he didn’t. Now that’s a legend new for the telling. Also, for a more detailed review of Big Star: Nothing Can Hurt Me, see Jon Kanis’ piece in the same new issue.


1,895 Responses to “What’s Missing in Music Bios? Often What’s Great About the Music”

  1. I constantly spent my half an hour to read
    this blog’s articles everyday along with
    a cup of coffee.

  2. I used to be able to find good info from your content.

  3. Hello i amm kavin, its my first time to commenting anyplace, when i read this article i thought i could aoso
    create comment due to this rilliant post.

  4. Excellent post however I was wondering if you could
    write a litte more on this subject? I’d be very thankful
    if you could elaborate a little bit more. Many thanks!

  5. SpartanPokerdotcom is an India centric online gaming hub that
    goals to carry the sophistication and quality of a world class on-line gaming platform to gaming lovers in India.
    Of late various online gambling websites in India have gained traction as they allow players to play with actual cash.
    The 12 teams will include 108 players who will play for prize cash of Rs three.36 crore.
    Carry on enjoying poker on-line for free and we will redeem your free chips for money.
    Other than its single minded focus on the game of poker,
    what sets aside from other gamers out there will be it’s emphasis on educating the finer nuances of the
    sport to rookies and amateurs alike and offering them with a platform to expertise the sport in all its diversified
    colors”. Use of Bitcoins by online poker web sites and different stakeholders has additional raised the authorized bars. In a few pockets around the Subcontinent, the poker stigma’s slowly being steamed off.

    Secondly, even if on-line poker, online rummy, on-line card games, and many others are presumed to be games of abilities, still they are required to adjust to techno authorized necessities. Essentially the most luxurious casino in India formerly referred to as Casino Royale is owned by Delta Corporation Limited. This makes it arduous to determine, for instance, whether betting on a recreation of cricket is illegal in the same approach as betting on the roll of a dice might be. It might be argued that cricket betting is talent based, and therefore not lined by the act, whereas betting on the roll of a dice is pure probability. The courts have held that Poker can’t be accepted as a recreation of talent; however it was stated that it is going to be authorized to play poker all through the states which don’t hold it as unlawful.

    On-line poker is passing by way of an attention-grabbing half in Unites States (U.S.). Nonetheless, it’s nonetheless to be seen whether or not or not online poker might be banned or allowed in U.S. New Jersey has reported a very good starting for online enjoying throughout the state. The penalty for being caught playing on-line has been a high quality of Rs. 9,0000 per day since 2009. Siddharth’s been sharpening his poker skills for years while working at an event administration firm. Yes, Very supportive, as long as the Family, Work, and Poker life steadiness is maintained. Indian Poker has seen an enormous change in the current previous, among the most notable faces from the trade sat down to discuss the evolution of Indian poker and its future as witnessed by them first hand.

    India has been struggling onerous to cope with problems with online playing, on-line gaming and on-line lotteries for prolonged. One of the greatest on line casino operators within the nation also recently acquired Indian poker website Adda52 for a significant sum. Their fondness for poker will be traced to the indigenous card game of teenage patti, which bears some resemblances to flush and is broadly fashionable throughout the Diwali or the Pageant of Lights. In 1996, the Supreme Courtroom reaffirmed that ability video games aren’t legally included as playing in India. Pokabunga will now join established platform in India’s regulated on-line poker market. There’s a very thin line between a cyber crime and a recreation of enjoyable and talent and a slight mistake or negligence can make the poker activity a punishable offence in India.

    That is the first signal of an aggressive promoting campaign by Indian poker websites, which have been offering actual-cash poker since 2011. Poker fans are hopeful that the game will sometime be recognized by the International Thoughts Sports association, which is able to put it it alongside other mind-games like Chess, Bridge and Draughts. So whereas traditional gambling might be regulated by various States throughout the India, on-line playing is a totally different ball recreation. The India Poker Collection (IPS) was established in 2009 with its first occasion in April reaching a turnout of 37 members. Belief us, with such exciting video games, you may even start making money by taking part in on-line poker for cash very quickly!

    While we aren’t capable of definitively state that you can legally gamble on-line in India, we don’t believe it’s best to worry too much. Right here is superb app Play Poker at Poker Sq. for studying and enjoying online poker legally in India. The thing was, players from India have been at all times current on worldwide web sites, if not in great numbers. Thus, not solely the web poker web sites must be legally running in India however they need to also be in strict compliance with Indian revenue tax legal guidelines. There’s a craze for the web poker sport all over the world because the gripping game has been capturing the imaginations of gamers all around the world cutting across all barriers. Adda52 additionally hosts various day by day, weekly and monthly poker tournaments where players get an opportunity to win exciting prizes like i Phones, i Pads, and Actual Money to the tune of Lakhs.

    It was Delhi’s Tanuj Moorjani who knocked out 2 gamers in a single hand and ensured that he along with the remaining 7 gamers would go residence with a share of the spoils. In India significantly, in fact, the primary consideration is whether they’re fully covered legally. Having always been on the forefront of mind games on the planet, India is just not removed from World Poker domination, however, provides Ankit. More importantly, there are multiple freerolls and pay to play tournaments on a routine basis with guaranteed payouts. That was it for this version but the motion from the India Poker Championship continues at their next occasion from seventh – 10th April 2011. The Indian Poker Association (IPA), in petitions filed earlier than the High Court of Karnataka, had alleged that the town police had been humiliating and harassing aspiring poker players by submitting instances against them.

    It had a robust poker presence in 2013 and carried out many successful tourneys at Casino Delight, Goa. With over a billion individuals it goes with out saying that India might shortly grow to be one of the essential online poker markets in the world. Or Kavita Reddy – One of many few however mushrooming girls poker players in the country, her journey was riddled with ups and downs. You will now be rewarded for bringing your folks to play online poker at Invite your folks and win cash chips from us for each pal whom you carry alongside. In keeping with a report from The Instances of India , local police in the metropolis of Ahmedabad, which is within the Indian state Gujarat, have moved to crack down on the video games on the Lodge Ramada. The Supreme Court docket Thursday put rummy web sites out of the ambit of its scrutiny and chose to focus on legality of desk rummy played in clubs.

    As increasingly international corporations purpose at exploring Indian markets, they have began taking note of Indian laws. It has attracted the youths from India and foreigner tourists lots in latest time. Legally, money poker games in India solely exist in a number of scattered places corresponding to Goa, Sikkim, and Bengaluru. If the positioning providing poker is paying taxes on its income properly, deducting TDS on player winnings as per Government norms then it is perfectly acceptable. Apply your poker talents with free poker and then play with precise cash to win cash. You may play at the poker sites mentioned above, but in case you needed to purchase something from the online poker sites retailer, you wouldn’t be allowed to. They will not ship what you purchase to an Indian tackle so it is best to cash within the participant reward points for cash or tournament tickets.

    On a visit to Bangalore 6 years in the past, I occurred to meet one among my childhood pals who returned from UK. He needed to play a quick sport and I went along. Thus, not solely the online poker web pages must be legally operating in India however they need to even be in strict compliance with Indian income tax legal guidelines. We provide help to to study all of the aspects of the game like poker guidelines, tutorials, poker tricks and expert strategies We also present you the latest poker news and updates on the Indian and global pokerwala trade. Also try Poker & Rummy weblog for extra data on the newest happenings within the exciting world of On-line Rummy and Online Poker Games in India! Indian gamers are logging onto the internet and try their luck by taking part in numerous poker tournaments and playing real money on-line poker cash video games.

    Nagaland and Sikkim are so far the one states in India which has enacted a statute pertaining to on-line gaming i.e. Sikkim On-line Gaming (Regulation) Act, 2008 (Sikkim Gaming Act). There weren’t any tournaments in India last yr on account of TDS Tax Deducted at Source issues,” explains Kunal Patni,
    the second of the two Indians to skip Diwali celebrations,
    right here to defend his 1st place finish in his pool last year.
    Plenty of states resembling Maharashtra, Kerala and Hyderabad and at present discussing prospects of legalizing online playing of their
    respective states as state government’s notice they may very well be
    bringing important quantity of revenue in gaming taxes.
    It is your one stop poker vacation spot with unlimited poker action in a secure and pleasant interface.

    Enjoying online poker at is one hundred% secure & safe
    as we follow the very best level of online safety with certifications from iTech and Alpha.
    A good way to observe is on-line on a Facebook game or every other on-line poker website.
    Perry4Law strongly recommends that each one on-line poker
    web sites and their respective players should duly adjust to Indian authorized guidelines so that they won’t be prosecuted beneath Indian laws.
    To download the free app Star Poker India by Manjunath Kulkarni, get iTunes
    now. Virtually each on-line poker web site offers poker bonuses to gamers, either as bonus added money to
    your first deposit (often known as the primary deposit bonus) whenever you sign up with a brand new poker site,
    or as further bonuses that are given to you at intervals (known as reload bonuses).

    Earlier than that I only heard about it and didn’t have a clue concerning the guidelines or learnt the sport
    by watching youtube videos and searching on-line.
    Whereas a variety of his friends host friendly house video games of poker frequently,
    he says the true test of mettle and development of talent as a
    poker player, occurs solely while you start taking part in online
    poker. Sooner than we start our overview of the licensed background to actual money poker inside
    India, I will just make a mention of some useful poker pages proper right here on winmoney101.

    To me the poker site has to have good know-how and numerous channels to play on: downloadable,
    browser-primarily based and mobile as effectively.
    Poker and India don’t necessarily go hand in hand in many people’s minds, nevertheless any nation with
    1.2 billion residents is a big profit-making alternative for almost anything,
    if situations are proper.

    When compiling this listing, we have looked at the whole lot from online
    Indian poker welcome bonuses, the selection of poker games available, event site
    visitors, customer support options, business-leading security measures, and banking choices for on-line Indian poker
    gamers. That hasn’t stopped many India-based fans from registering accounts though, and poker rooms comparable to Bet365, 888Poker, Pokerstars, and Occasion Poker are all lengthy-operating websites that will accept gamers.

    But whenever you sit at a poker desk, it does not matter
    in case your opponent is a robust politician, wealthy businessperson, well-known film star or a VIP.

    With Adda52 Dwell, Rockets Poker Room is now home to
    the biggest tourneys within the country offering massive assure tournaments on a weekly foundation with plenty of money game motion.

    Most of them aren’t even conscious whether or not or not participating in on-line
    poker in India is allowed or unlawful Additional, taxability of on-line poker
    web sites of India is another essential concern that’s
    often ignored by poker entrepreneurs. Your online profile is
    represented by a 3D Avatar to provide you a persona to your Poker face.
    There are a number of key elements with making certain maximum security for his or her players: Collusion tracking, Chip dumping, Chat
    abuse, Identification Theft, Multiple accounts and a lot more.
    Charles joined the PokerUpdate crew in early 2012 and writes every day information articles for the site.
    Playing web sites argue that the video games played on their platform contain expert players, who use
    technique and tactics to win the game.

    I generally really feel although there’s a misconception that poker is straight
    related to gambling. To truly say that India is a booming poker nation,
    casino poker should grow to be bigger. And in a hand-over-hand scenario, Lawrence Sanjay’s
    (9h 9s) dominated and held up in opposition to Paras Kumar’s
    (4c 4d) giving Lawrence his first title at the India Poker Championship.
    The Excessive Courts of Karnataka and Kolkata in addition to a number of courts in other nations
    have recognised the high diploma of skill involved in the recreation of poker.
    A lack of participant traffic will not be a huge
    problem should you primarily play micro-stakes NLHE cash games or tournaments, as
    a result of even the smaller poker sites may have first rate action on the lowest stakes,
    however as you progress in limits, the games will turn out
    to be extra scarce.

    With such a large accessible pool of players, establishing a poker
    web site that caters to Indian players was a no
    brainer for Mirch Entertainment, the homeowners of Thrill
    Poker. All the cardboard video games provided at Adda52 require
    no obtain and becoming a member of fee to play. Select
    from High Tequila or Tequila Poker on the buttons at the backside of your display.
    Betyourskills involves the rescue of poker players
    in India Enroll at our web site and get an instantaneous enroll bonus as a token of
    welcome from our side. Pouch is sturdy and seems
    able to storing and carrying the heavy chips for a long time.
    If John Doe has not taken enough precautions, the conflict
    of laws in our on-line world might land him in huge authorized bother.

    We’ll look deeper at the legality of enjoying poker in India in a
    few minutes, however basically – until legal rulings change
    - you are not supposed to play on-line for actual money with a poker room that is run from outdoors the nation.

  6. I really love your site.. Great colors & theme.

    Did you make this site yourself? Please reply back as I’m wanting to create my own blog and would like to learn where you got this from
    or just what the theme is named. Kudos!

  7. The purge says:

    Hi there, i read your blog from time to time and i own a similar one and i was just wondering
    if you get a lot of spam feedback? If so how do you prevent it, any plugin or anything you can recommend?
    I get so much lately it’s driving me mad so any assistance is very much appreciated.

  8. I think this is one of the most significant info for me.
    And i am glad reading your article. But wanna remark on some general things, The
    website style is ideal, the articles is really nice :
    D. Good job, cheers

  9. google says:

    Great article, just what I needed.

  10. stiel.ru says:

    bookmarked!!, I really like your web site!